Hello dear
Welcome To The Mad Sicilian
At The Mad Sicilian, we celebrate the heart and soul of authentic Italian cuisine, right in the vibrant community of Petaluma, CA. Founded by passionate veterans of the culinary arts, our pizzeria specializes in Chicago-style deep dish and classic pizzas, crafted with fresh, local ingredients. Our commitment to excellence shines through in every dish, from our savory tortellini to our divine cannoli. With accessible dining options and a welcoming atmosphere, we prioritize hospitality and satisfaction. Join us for happy hour specials, private dining, or a delightful family outing, and experience why we are more than just a pizzeria; we’re a culinary masterpiece.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Creamy Ranch
$2.50Zorbas Salad
$8.50Club Lucky
$37.00
Twin Anchors
$35.00The 226 Club
$39.00Gioco GeeOCo
$41.00
Room 21
$39.00Lotties Pub
$38.00Authentic Chicago Style
$30.00 About
The Mad Sicilian
Welcome to The Mad Sicilian, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Petaluma, California. This vibrant spot at 203 N McDowell Blvd masterfully reinterprets classic Italian cuisine, with a star focus on Chicago-style pizza. Whether you're a deep dish devotee or a thin crust lover, they promise to elevate your pizza experience to glorious new heights.
At The Mad Sicilian, every bite tells a story. Picture this: the Club Lucky, an authentic Chicago deep-dish creation, combines Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and black olives tucked under a generously crafted crust. It's a hearty dish that is both celebrated and beloved, as noted by customers who rave about its full flavor and fresh, local ingredients. Timothy Hudson, an enthusiastic patron, remarks, "Incredibly fresh local ingredients. Full of flavor and worth the stop."
This family-owned establishment takes pride in crafting its dishes with love and expertise. The accolades don’t stop there; the Twin Anchors option features double Italian sausage and a zesty pizza sauce that embodies the essence of traditional Chicago pizza. According to Bowman McNear, "By far the best pizza in Petaluma," where the respect for authentic flavors shines through each pie.
The menu at The Mad Sicilian extends beyond pizza. Diners can indulge in rich cannolis, praised by many for their perfect sweetness, balanced beautifully with walnuts and dark chocolate. Cynthia Valenzuela, a local food enthusiast, describes them as "wonderful," emphasizing their delightful texture. The culinary marvels don’t end here—don’t overlook their exquisite crème brulee, which has left mouths watering for days, as shared by another delighted guest.
Moreover, The Mad Sicilian's commitment to exceptional service and a warm atmosphere truly enhances the dining experience. Many guests speak volumes about the friendly and dedicated staff, who strive to make each visit memorable. As local food lover Mike Trouchon enthusiastically states, “The customer service was superb.”
- Location: 203 N McDowell Blvd, Petaluma, CA 94954
- Phone: (707) 766-8600
- Signature Dish: Chicago Style Pizza
- Highlights: Housemade marinara, delicious cannoli, and exceptional customer service
- Dining Atmosphere: Cozy and welcoming, perfect for families
In summary, The Mad Sicilian is not just a pizzeria; it is a culinary experience that invites food lovers to savor Italian flavors with a unique twist. With exceptional dishes, fresh ingredients, and a friendly atmosphere, a visit here is a celebration of community and cuisine. Don’t miss out on the chance to discover why this place is becoming Petaluma’s favorite pizza destination!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great Pizza. Ordered the Deepdish Chicago with Sausage. Incredibly fresh local ingredients. Full of flavor and worth the stop. The staff is friendly and dedicated to making the best pizza I have ever had. This is more than pizza but a culinary master piece! We should have taken pictures before devouring our first piece. ”
“ The past two orders Ive had have been great I absolutely loved the Luciano It was so flavorful and you can just tell that the marinara sauce is in housemade and its so delicious. The cannolis are so delicious I really like that they arent too sweet and the walnuts and dark chocolate really compliment the filling. The creme brulee is so divine I was craving it for days and I had to order it again Im so pleased with my orders. Im so excited to try more in the future ”
“ By far the best pizza in Petaluma, both regular crust and deep dish. I was amazed to find a place that can cook deep dish pizza identical to my favorite pizzeria in Chicago. Also, the monthly special pizzas are a great way to try unusual toppings youve never had before ”
“ This was my first time at The Mad Sicilian and I had to try their deep dish pie. I got mine with linguica, artichoke hearts, and black olives and it was the best deep dish pie Ive ever had! Incredibly delicious! Plus the customer service was superb. Support your local Sicilian pizzeria. ”
“ My first visit and I will return. The tomato sauce tastes like fresh tomatoes. Ask for fresh roasted garlic on your pizza. And the cannoli is wonderful! Not gritty or too sweet and grated chocolate not mini chips. Owner and wife are so kind and friendly. A neighborhood Gem! ”
“ Great pizza and service! Made and served with soul. Atmosphere was a little lack luster, but the food more than makes up for it. We ordered both a Neapolitan style and deep dish. Both awesome. ”
“ We decided to eat here after we saw a few highly rated yelp reviews and oh my they didnt disappoint! All my cheesey dreams came true! The tomatoes sauce on top was perfectly balanced! Dont forget to add roasted garlic! The hunky Sicilian man herd my cry when I realized I could have added some to my pizza and added it anyway definitely a must! Do yourself a favor and eat here for dinner ”
“ Me and my husband were out at Dillion beach, and on our way home we live in the valley we wanted some pizza so I googled pizza...and here we ended up! This place was delicious, the crust had so much flavor which blew us away. The sauce wasnt too salty, lots of flavor and same for the meat! We got meatballs on the house, and we ordered their breadsticks. The owner made the ordering experience personable and checked on us multiple times, that was so refreshing and left s lasting impression on us. I would drive over an hour just to go eat there again, thats for sure! ”